Skip to main content

AI Pitfalls Every Realtor Should Avoid (And What to Do Instead)

Published Date
Author Joanna Harrison

AI can supercharge your real estate business, or send you scrambling. The difference lies in understanding where AI excels and where it fails catastrophically. Here are the costly mistakes agents are making and how to avoid them.

The Legal Advice Trap

The Mistake: Using ChatGPT to answer legal questions about contracts, disclosure requirements, or transaction regulations.

Why It's Dangerous: AI models aren't trained on current local real estate law and can provide confidently wrong information that could expose you to liability. Real estate regulations vary by state and change frequently.

What to Do Instead: Use AI to help you articulate questions for your broker or real estate attorney. Prompt example: "Help me organize my questions about [situation] for my legal consultation. What key details should I include and what follow-up questions should I ask?"

The Fake Data Disaster

The Mistake: Asking AI to generate market statistics, comparable sales data, or property values.

Why It's Dangerous: AI models will confidently create realistic-looking but completely fabricated numbers. Presenting false market data to clients destroys credibility and could constitute fraud.

What to Do Instead: Use AI to help interpret and present real data you've gathered from MLS, county records, or market reports. Prompt: "Explain these market trends [paste actual data] in simple terms for first-time buyers, highlighting what's most relevant to their decision."

The Generic Content Curse

The Mistake: Publishing AI-generated content without local customization or personal insight.

Why It's Hurting You: Generic content makes you invisible in a crowded market. Clients can spot templated content immediately, and it signals that you're not truly engaged with your local market.

What to Do Instead: Use AI as a starting point, then layer in local knowledge, recent transactions, and personal experiences. Transform "Downtown has great restaurants" into "I just helped clients find a home three blocks from Husk, where they celebrated their engagement—that kind of walkable lifestyle is exactly why downtown is seeing 15% faster sales."

The Separate Systems Scramble

The Mistake: Using AI in piecemeal fashion, to handle client communications, but not syncing properly with your technology platform.

Why It Fails: Real estate is fundamentally a relationship business, and your communication is critical. So is your time, so scaling this can be difficult, and leveraging AI to draft communication and keep clients in the loop is great, unless it’s creating more manual work as you work from multiple systems and are not logging communication data or leveraging a smart CRM to give you proactive notification. 

What to Do Instead: Using a system like BoldTrail, a platform with baked-in AI means all your systems and tools are talking, seamlessly. With BoldTrail’s HomeSearch AI,  let clients search the way they actually speak on your website, and then automatically creates and sends automated alerts based on natural language, which drives higher open rates, better engagement, and more conversations that lead to closings.HomeSearch AI learns and improves over time, too, reengaging cold leads at the right moment with listings that match their intent, and keeping clients on your site and in your pipeline.



The Over-Automation Trap

The Mistake: Automating so much of your business that you lose touch with market nuances and client needs.

Why It's Risky: Markets shift quickly, and AI models lag behind real-time changes. Over-reliance on automation can make you miss emerging trends or fail to adapt your approach when market conditions change.

What to Do Instead: Use the 80/20 rule—let AI handle 80% of the routine work so you can spend 80% of your time on high-value activities like client relationships, market analysis, and strategic thinking.

Video: Want to see how AI is revolutionizing home search and follow up? Watch now! https://resources.insiderealestate.com/trending/ai-innovation-jeff-alissa

The Accuracy Assumption

The Mistake: Publishing AI-generated content without fact-checking, especially about local regulations, market conditions, or property details.

Why It's Costly: Inaccurate information spreads quickly and damages your reputation. One wrong detail about zoning laws or school districts can cost you clients and referrals.

What to Do Instead: Implement a verification system. For every AI-generated claim, identify the source you'll check. Create templates like: "Before publishing, verify: market statistics with [MLS/source], school information with [district website], zoning with [county records]."

The Privacy and Confidentiality Breach

The Mistake: Inputting client personal information, confidential transaction details, or proprietary market data into AI tools.

Why It's Dangerous: Most AI platforms store and potentially use your inputs for training. Sharing client information could violate privacy laws and your professional obligations.

What to Do Instead: Always anonymize data before using AI tools. Instead of "Help me negotiate for the Smith family buying 123 Main Street," use "Help me craft negotiation strategies for buyers concerned about appraisal risk in a competitive market."

The Red Flags Checklist

Before using AI for any real estate task, ask yourself:

  • Does this require current, local, or legal knowledge that AI might not have?

  • Could incorrect information harm my client or my reputation?

  • Am I using this to avoid developing important professional skills?

  • Does this involve confidential client information?

  • Would I be comfortable if my clients knew AI generated this content?

AI that Drives Results 

AI is a powerful amplifier, it makes good agents better and exposes weaknesses in mediocre agents. The professionals thriving with AI aren't using it to replace their expertise; they're using it to free up time and mental energy for the high-value work that only humans can do.

Use AI to handle the routine so you can focus on the remarkable. Your clients will notice the difference. Ready to leverage AI that’s baked into your platform to drive meaningful results? BoldTrail’s platform has you covered. Plus, with the new HomeSearch AI, it’s never been easier to deliver an unparalleled experience to your clients. Let them search like they talk, tailor search alerts to keep them engaged, automatically, and reengage old leads at just the right moment, without any extra effort. It’s the gamechanger you need.

See BoldTrail in action!