Skip to main content

From Churn to Champions: From Agent Turnover Into Retention Wins

Published Date
Author Joanna Harrison

Agents are rethinking their affiliations and seeking more value from their brokerages and teams, but retention isn’t just a nice-to-have, it’s a growth strategy you need to succeed.

The good news? Retention doesn’t happen by chance. When leaders take an intentional approach to supporting agents, solving pain points, and building a culture that empowers success, they turn churn into opportunity, and their agents into advocates.

Here’s how high-performing teams and brokerages are turning retention challenges into strategic wins.

1. Understand Why Agents Leave (and Why They Stay)

Before you can fix retention, you need to understand your churn. Agents don’t leave for one single reason—there’s usually a combination of unmet needs, lack of support, or misalignment with leadership.

Common drivers of turnover include:

  • Lack of leads or consistent income

  • Poor onboarding and training experiences

  • Disconnected or outdated technology

  • Feeling undervalued or unsupported

  • Weak brand presence or marketing tools

On the flip side, agents who stay, and are thriving, often cite leadership, culture, quality of support, and access to business-building tools as key reasons. Want to know where you stand? Ask. Anonymous surveys, one-on-ones, and exit interviews can uncover patterns and highlight opportunities for success in recruiting and retaining top talent. 

2. Build a Clear Value Stack

Agents aren’t just comparing commission splits, they’re evaluating the total value your team or brokerage brings to their business. That means it’s critical to clearly communicate and deliver on your value stack: the combination of tools, services, support, and leadership you provide.

This includes things like:

  • High-quality lead generation and routing

  • Smart, centralized CRM systems

  • Marketing support and automation

  • Transaction coordination and compliance help

  • Coaching, mentoring, and goal tracking

Platforms like BoldTrail help you showcase and scale that value, with tools like an integrated Smart CRM, lead gen suite, branded websites, and performance dashboards, all in one login. When agents feel equipped to succeed, they’re less likely to look elsewhere.

It’s also a powerful recruitment tool. See how Samson Properties recruits over 100 new agents per month. 

3. Prioritize Agent Onboarding & Early Wins

Retention starts on day one. The first 90 days are critical for setting expectations, building habits, and proving your value as a leader.

Top teams have structured onboarding programs that help new agents get connected, close deals faster, and feel like part of the team. Clear milestones, tech walkthroughs, and early coaching can reduce friction and increase agent confidence—both key factors in long-term retention.

And when your front office and back office systems are connected (like with BoldTrail’s upcoming Back Office Suite), onboarding becomes even smoother, ensuring agents are productive without being overwhelmed.

4. Make Performance Visible (and Coachable)

People stay where they grow. A key driver of retention is ongoing coaching and performance management, but you can’t coach what you can’t see.

Real-time visibility into agent activity, conversion metrics, and pipeline health allows leaders to spot roadblocks early and offer meaningful, personalized support. This turns underperformance into a coaching opportunity—not a quiet exit.

BoldTrail’s Vitals tool gives team leaders access to the insights that matter—without endless spreadsheets or guesswork. When agents know you’re invested in their success and not just tracking them for the sake of it, they’re more engaged and stay loyal.

5. Build a Culture of Recognition and Collaboration

Culture is the glue that holds your team together. Agents want to feel like they’re part of something meaningful, not just a number. Recognition, collaboration, and shared wins all contribute to a strong sense of belonging.

That doesn’t mean forced fun or pizza Fridays. It means:

  • Celebrating agent milestones and success stories

  • Encouraging mentorship and peer support

  • Giving agents a voice in business decisions

  • Creating a space where agents know their work matters

When your team’s tools, communication channels, and leadership style reflect a collaborative, supportive environment, culture becomes your retention advantage.

Want to make sure you have every advantage in your corner? Learn more about how BoldTrail can drive success